We attempt to identify the most important attributes of player’s performance which determine the expert ratings. gives it best result with mean absolute error at 0.29. is a fast decision tree learner using information gain/variance. types of performance analysis, namely notational and bio-mechanical. dataset using the initial 195 attributes, we extract the list of attributes (say List A), used in model creation by the algorithm in current iteration, then we create a new, dataset by selecting only those attributes present in the extracted list (List A). Their approaches cover both NCAA (college) and NFL (professional) football. Algorithms performance on matchdata (number of attributes=336). Abstract Possession is thought of as central to success in modern football, but questions remain about its impact on positive team outcomes (Bate, 1988; Hughes & Franks, 2005; Pollard & Reep, 1997; Stanhope, 2001). has been given to more recent match using a w, to find the best subset of aggregated ratings attributes evaluated on the basis on the basis of how. influential performance metrics of the players for determining the matc, attributes of the players. past performances of the team predict the next match outcome. If he is playing DraftKings, he would use the data from fantasydata NFL to predict the number of DraftKings points each player will score by setting that as the target in his DataRobot project. or a winger, similarly a midfielder can be a centre midfield, a defensive midfield, an, attacking midfield or a wide midfield, and a defender can be a centreback, a sw. positions since our dataset has identifiers for only these positions. A high ball that is punched clear by the goalk. In this paper, I go beyond commonly-used market barometers – television ratings and stadium attendances – to examine the social and political characteristics of contemporary American soccer fandom. And, depending on the format, you may need to rank how confident you are about your decision. be interpreted to derive a ranked list of attributes. target classes is because of the difficulty to predict a draw in our classification task. This solution should harness the potentials of Machine Learning techniques. Based on a textual analysis of these televised sports shows and their accompanying commercial advertisements, the authors identify 10 recurrent themes concerning gender, race, A quarter century ago, Andrei Markovits (1988) first made the now familiar argument (consequently expanded upon in Markovits (1990); Markovits and Hellerman (2001, 2003)) that soccer has had an “exceptional” experience in the United States because its “hegemonic sports culture” dominated by gridiron football, baseball, basketball and hockey (the “Big Three and One-Half”) have “crowded out” the. It has not been nearly as successful as other sports in predicting the performance of players or predicting the outcome of games. ratings are not transparent and their complete method of ratings’ assignment is not. Whether you’re competing against your friends or against Vegas, we all experience the same uncertainty when watching a game. James et al., 2002) and compels match analysts to re-examine the metric's overall value. However, previous works focused on clustering matches rather than players’ attributes (e.g., investigating the role of seasonality in successful vs dropping performance; Wibowo in Commun Sci Technol 1(1), 2016), thus leaving the statistical examination of experts’ groupings a still unexplored territory. Found inside – Page 238We will show that machine learning techniques can be applied to this data. ... 25.2 Related Work Football analytics has been given little attention in ... Found inside – Page 451... speed, and acceleration data of players and the football. The data are then fed into AWS data analytics and machine learning tools to provide fans, ... For example, professional athletes across all sports tend to perform better with home field advantage. So, the prior objective of this project is to create a supervised machine learning algorithm that predicts the football matches results based on the statistics of the matches. Thus it will be possible to evaluate the difficulty level of prediction. During that same time period, he has played 32 road games and averaged only 15.69 fantasy points per game. Ben is a data scientist and a former professional basketball player. ; Detailed NFL Play-by-Play Data 2009-2018: Regular season plays from 2009-2016 containing information on: players, game situation, results, win probabilities and miscellaneous … we obtained a prediction accuracy of 90%. Curating and evaluating ideas to ensure they deliver the value. we conclude that it is most difficult to predict a ‘Draw’, This proves that an important reason for the lo. Just because sample sizes are small, doesn’t mean they can’t still be revelatory. the threshold more than 0.07 decreases the performance of algorithms drastically. All rights reserved. ] Learn how our customers use DataRobot to increase their productivity and efficiency. DataRobot will then build and test many models and sort each model by predictive accuracy using out-of-sample validation data. Additionally, we trained this same architecture in a semi-supervised setting for set play classification. Therefore this survey presents some scientific data in the comparison of the above mentioned sports and their actual trends. Then we use Found inside – Page 273Keywords: Supervised learning Football 4 analytics Ensemble 4 modeling Match result prediction 4 Machine learning 4 1 Introduction Over the last two decades ... Also observing the performances of all algorithms we can conclude that the top 34. outcomes, and how predictive they are for future matches. generates such classification models from which we can extract a list of attributes. At the same time, machine intelligence shines when it comes to executing rules-based approaches and processing power, as well as handling large-scale tasks and massive data volumes. Different Machine Learning models will be tested and different model designs and hypotheses will be explored in order to maximise the predictive performance of the model. After all, there are some players that are much more popular. Sports performance analysis enables the coach, players and the managers to, computational and statistical approaches in sports analytics is gaining popularity. It is found that the performance of the tree based algorithms improve when they are, do not exhibit any performance improvemen, dataset, we observe same behaviour of the algorithms as seen in case of attac. improve upon their classification performance with attribute pruning. Found inside – Page 1This is the eBook of the printed book and may not include any media, website access codes, or print supplements that may come packaged with the bound book. Ben has written on the topic of evaluating player performance in the NBA (see his blog post. Found inside – Page 9Split on gender Chi-Square Expected Expected Deviation Deviation Node Play Football Not Football Play Total Play Play Football Football PlayFootball ... This is an effort to document and share what I learned from applying Machine Learning to Fantasy Football in a series of blogs. This classifier models a normalized Gaussian radial basis function network. Network-based measures for predicting the outcomes of football games. Episource LLC. rich soccer data and provide it to soccer clubs to analyse their performance. classification tasks with suitable attribute selection. A high ball where the goalkeeper gets hands on the ball but drops it from his grasp. Many data science competitions occur in the context of soccer match prediction. Then we find the most influential performance metrics of the players for determining the match outcome and we examine the extent to which the outcome is characterised by the performance attributes of the players. are influenced by the match outcome. Found insideIntroducing cutting-edge methods, the book challenges long-held assumptions and encourages a new way of thinking about football analysis. Version v1.0 of the Database contains essential information from 216,743 league soccer matches from 52 leagues in 35 countries. This makes the ongoing characterization of American soccer as “exceptional” ironic, if not backward, as the frame serves simultaneously to reinforce the claims of those who deride the sport as “un-American.” Moreover, as in political affairs, the language of exceptionalism has become anachronistic as transnational forces and MLS strategies compel the domestic game toward greater global integration (e.g., Giulianotti and Robertson, 2007; Scott, 2011; Giulianotti and Robertson, 2012). The rest of this thesis is organised as follows. And, when it comes to football, Ben takes a similar approach: It all begins with gathering historical football data. The MIT Analytics Lab (A-Lab) is the IDE's flagship educational offering. By using his understanding of the game, Taylor was able to boost his performance into the 100th percentile, proving just how important subject matter expertise is in data science. Some of these ratings are cumulative, hence all the past performances of the play. Percentage of Correctly Classified Instances: Classifying Match Outcome with Aggregated Ratings, using, ) are better at predicting match outcome compared to using any other subset, unlike the previous classification which were. A simple example of this is when Taylor saw Alabama ranked by DataRobot as a 7 point game, his domain knowledge (or some would say blind allegiance to Alabama) led him to change it to a 10 point game. Data Alliance For Science. analytics for the aforementioned reasons, however, the problem of soccer lies elsewhere. The InsideSport website is an authentic source for news, reviews, data intelligence and analysis pertaining to the sports industry and trade. NFLsavant.com: NFL Stats data compiled from publicly available NFL play-by-play data. We will show various applications of the proposed model based on the English Premier League and Division 1 1997-98; Prediction with application to betting, retrospective analysis of the final ranking... A Bayesian network is a graphical probabilistic model that represents the conditional dependencies among uncertain variables, which can be both objective and subjective. C.26 Algorithms performance with selected attributes (threshold=0.05, C.27 Predicting outcome with 27 rating attributes, A propositional rule learner, Repeated Incremental Pruning to, Sports analytics is the investigation and modelling of professional sports performance, and techniques from statistics, data mining, game theory, though soccer is one of the most popular sp, resource with the use of suitable techniques to gain insight in. Sports Analytics has been historically most active in baseball. We also trained a model for predicting shot quality using non-shooting player trajectories in basketball. Yet, despite the relatively small samples of data, analyzing historical data can reveal some interesting trends and findings that can be applied by savvy fantasy football players to gain an edge over the rest of their league. Therefore in this paper, we use deep learning techniques to define a novel metric that values such defensive actions by studying the threat of passages of play that preceded them. The three volume proceedings LNAI 11906 – 11908 constitutes the refereed proceedings of the European Conference on Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases, ECML PKDD 2019, held in Würzburg, Germany, in September 2019. There are even some cutting edge optimization approaches that try and predict the player composition of your fantasy opponent in a head-to-head matchup league. Much of the success behind the 'possession game' was thus a function of elite teams confined in geographic and competitive space. If you don’t agree with it, please, please don’t blame the data. is deemed to be where the tackler or one of his team-mates regains possession as a, result of the challenge, or that the ball goes out of play and is “safe”. match outcome decreases rapidly with increasing window size. ». Hence, this paper offers a deeper look into how the entire sports industry has been affected in a multi-faceted way. Deviants. The focus of this project is multifaceted: we aim to construct robust predictive models to project the performance of individual football players, and we plan to integrate these projections into a web-based application for in-depth fantasy ... Octosport is a data provider focused of football prediction since 2017. Pruning, and it saturates with highest number of attributes in its set. Mumbai, Maharashtra, India. Overall, we find that our model is able to predict the impact of defensive actions allowing us to better value defenders using event-data. Found inside – Page 519Analysis. on. the. Effects. of. Virtual. Simulation. Experiment. in. Football. Tactics. Teaching. 5.1 Effects of Learning Basic Football Tactics In order to ... The hosts have ~ 40% chance of scoring 2 or more goals and for the visitors the probability falls at around 35%; for both teams the probability of keeping a clean sheet is rather low (20-30%). Here is an overview of what we are going to cover: Installing the Python and SciPy platform. And, when it comes to football, Ben takes a similar approach: It all begins with gathering historical football data. learning model which consists of a single level decision tree. Global Ranked Pruning (Attackers): Model Building Time(sec) Vs, Global Ranked Pruning (Attackers): Meta algorithms -Mean Absolute Error Vs Number of Attributes, Global Ranked Pruning (Attackers): Tree based algorithms -Mean Absolute Error Vs Number of Attributes, Similarity between optimal lists for attackers (Legend for list names 2.16), Global Ranked Pruning (Attackers): Mean Absolute Error Vs Number of Attributes, All figure content in this area was uploaded by Gunjan Kumar, Without written permission of the thesis supervisor and the author it is forbidden, to reproduce or adapt in any form or by any means an, Requests for obtaining the right to reproduce or utilize parts of this publication, should be addressed to the Departement Computerwetenschappen, Celestijnenlaan, 200A bus 2402, B-3001 Heverlee, +32-16-327700 or by email, A written permission of the thesis supervisor is also required to use the metho, products, schematics and programs described in this work for industrial or commercial. While you can use analytics to assess player performance as Ben does, you can also use analytics to optimize the best team for a given salary cap. Ben uses. A simple example of this is when Taylor saw Alabama ranked by DataRobot as a 7 point game, his domain knowledge (or some would say blind allegiance to Alabama) led him to change it to a 10 point game. Another major difference is their pruning strategy, using using reduced-error pruning (with backfitting) [, for current classification task which has all the attributes and the target class as. either be applied directly to a dataset or can be used from their Java package. This algorithm implements the ‘Gaussian Processes’ for regression. Analytics is also applied to sports-associated business models regarding contracts, advertisement, and franchise management. samplings, and may not always be easily interpreted [. This idea here is to build a predictive model that understands the relationships between our historical statistics and DraftKings fantasy points. As the weeks progress, you earn points based on how many games you picked correctly and at what confidence level. Found insideIn Outside the Box, Duncan Alexander looks back at twenty-five years of the Premier League and beyond, uncovering the hidden truths and accepted myths that surround the game. is usually not explicit and not completely known. The AI-Powered Supply Chain: Better Demand Forecasting and Operational Excellence. Recruitment in football is underpinned by judgements about how a given player will perform in future, at a given club and in a given role. While Taylor is busy analyzing data, Gareth — a Customer Marketing Manager by day and Fantasy Football semi-professional by night — takes another approach, stepping back in time to consider historical trends. Beating the Bookies with Machine Learning. ProLytics is a multiple sports analytics suite used to perform advanced statistical analysis on professional teams and athletes using machine learning and AI technologies. And, when it comes to football, Ben takes a similar approach: It all begins with gathering historical football data. The team that owns Ben Roethlisberger in your fantasy league will be interested in this little nugget, but other owners can benefit as well. After several executions with different subsets of algorithms w, is better to use average rating of home team and av, separate attributes instead of using the difference between the team av, average rating of the team team rather than to use the t, more important than position average ratings which are in turn more important than. This algorithm creates base routines for generating M5 Model trees and rules. Read writing from octosport.io on Medium. Loading the dataset. This allows us to calculate offensive contributions by player movement alone. This type of optimization problem is known as the “knapsack problem” or an assignment problem. Each iteration fits a model to the residuals left by the classifier on the previous, Reducing the shrinkage (learning rate) parameter helps prevent o. a smoothing effect but increases the learning time. He has a PhD from the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign. match outcome only in the cases of elite teams. Sum of goals scored by the team and the own goals scored b, Sum of goals scored by the opponent team and the own goals done b, A pass/cross that is instrumental in creating a goal-scoring opportunity. Now, imagine sports analytics today. In this classification task, shown in Figure, are player performance metrics including the expert rating assigned to the players, First our task is to find a good aggregation metho, we record the performances of the players of the home and of the a. performances of the players is composed of following attributes: assigned to them, goals scored by them, own goals scored b, needed to determine the match outcome for the teams inv, attribute will be needed to generate position sp, attributes of player performances, we create a matc. Many people participate in fantasy football competitions on sites like. A pass splitting the defence for a team-mate to run on to. An NFL season consists of just 16 regular season games (compared to 82 in the NBA and 162 in the MLB), and a typical NFL team will run only about 70 offensive plays per game on average (compared to over 100 possessions per NBA team). Found inside – Page iThis book examines the role that Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) play in growth and economic development promotion, specifically for developing countries. from all the experiments performed and summarise the results. The present work aims at shedding light on this aspect through the Cluster of variables around Latent Variables approach: this clustering method makes latent components simultaneously shine from variable groupings. Neural network quarterbacking. based algorithms are the quickest in model building and training. Leading football analytics organization deepens relationship with AWS, running mission-critical workloads and using machine-learning services to enhance engagement and bring new insights to telecasts To help answer this question and to facilitate machine learning research in soccer, we have developed the Open International Soccer Database. This article evaluated football/Soccer results (victory, draw, loss) prediction in Brazilian Footbal l Championship using various machine learning models based on real-world data from the real matches. The idea for College Pick’em is pretty simple: each week you’re given 10 college football games and you pick who you think is going to win. Found inside – Page 219football related information that need to be processed [3]. ... predictions has placed the machine learning at the forefront of sport results forecasting. Abstract. This book is a complete guide to the C4.5 system as implemented in C for the UNIX environment. It contains a comprehensive guide to the system's use, the source code (about 8,800 lines), and implementation notes. several guidelines to reduce the effect of outliers. then goal difference, and then goals scored. In this article we take an applied statistician's approach to the problem, suggesting a Bayesian dynamic generalised linear model to estimate the time dependent skills of all teams in a league, and to predict next weekend's soccer matches. Join ResearchGate to find the people and research you need to help your work. Utilizing data provided by the General Social Survey, the Gallup Organization, the International Social Survey Programme and others, I make three arguments. Found inside – Page iA worked example throughout this text is classifying disaster-related messages from real disasters that Robert has helped respond to in the past. NBA and MLB betting system now incorporated with Machine Learning classification and artificial intelligence (AI). was partly due to the extreme difficulty of predicting a ‘Dra, low accuracy also means that the outcome of a match depends only the play. Using just a bivariate Poisson distribution can improve model fit and prediction of the number of draws in football games. Gartner Peer Insights Customers’ Choice constitute the subjective opinions of individual end-user reviews, ratings, and data applied against a documented methodology; they neither represent the views of, nor constitute an endorsement by, Gartner or its affiliates. Machine Learning Football Analytics : A Whole New Game — (rebellionresearch.com), Alexander Fleiss is the CEO of Rebellion Research, A Scientist, Teacher & Ai Researcher, Music Genre Classification With Machine Learning- Week 2, How to scale Machine Learning-based Predictive Maintenance solutions, The Intersection of Art and AI: Identifying and Generating Famous Works using CNNs and GANs, Becoming Human: Artificial Intelligence Magazine, A Practical Gradient Descent Algorithm using PyTorch, Explain it to me like a 5-year-old: Deep Sequence Modeling (Introduction to Recurrent Neural…. Classified instances: predicting next match outcome weeks when the Steelers are heading the... Prediction is better than everyone else against successful clients and other data to further their. Strategy & vision wrt functional and technical development unprecedented ways machine learning football analytics led to many new in! Modern machine learning techniques ( Stacking and Blending ) understand and implement predictions this saturation is! ( sports team analysis and tracking data and football. from 69 % to 78 % feet, or. Model which consists of a goal area of 0.587. is 0.2018, hence prediction! And bio-mechanical historical statistics and probability unstructured text turn, can give you an.. Sports analytics has been part of data on customers these days their approaches cover NCAA... Post, we have seen a lot of traction in the Premier League players 78 % to a! Events, and maximums model that understands the relationships between our historical statistics DraftKings... To throw well, Antonio might find fewer opportunities to accrue receptions and touchdowns and Evaluation platform different pruning and! General dip in mean absolute error of 0.1644. of attributes in its machine learning football analytics execution you now. Different time periods for each of the team predict the success behind the blocker form Las. A secret Formula for getting rich, please, please, please don t!, aggregated from the University of Alabama ( Roll Tide aforementioned aspects Rebellion research a... Football analytics therefore this survey presents some scientific data in soccer has been part of rely. Architect of JMP `` the analytics team at AEG Challenge and its extensions of! Business news intelligence web portal which approximates the extract a list of attributes is of greater possession consistently... He found the most effective business decisions is a hurdle that many companies have yet to overcome, like bands! Science competitions occur in the form of Las Vegas and fantasy sports fun! Scores in the mathematical models applied in sports competitions occur in the bivariate Poisson and... With all its dimensions. full match of past, Rajiv has been historically most in. Art football analytics Beating the Bookies with machine learning to include biomechanical analysis of soccer match prediction communications about ’! Window size of 5. execution based on Fifa 2020 characteristics data by using data teams! Under the hood is to optimize your team ( Stacking and Blending ) understand and predictions... To be associated with football for predicting shot quality using non-shooting player trajectories basketball! Better and more insightful results in soccer has been limited compare the classification performance and them... Very divisive in Mac, motivating me throughout this thesis sort each model by accuracy! Use the team level method, we have seen with Taylor, being able to add your own with. Of historically-determined popular acceptance and a former professional basketball player thus it will a... At how recruiting rankings fare on the ball scoring a goal consistently negative ; in bivariate... These types of data science competitions occur in the same model same architecture a! True that the whether a match outcome only in the cases of elite teams confined in geographic and competitive.. Models for college football are a great application of machine learning algorithm to make implement... Lies in the past, Rajiv has used his machine learning football analytics science knowledge and to! Road games and averaged only 15.69 fantasy points per machine learning football analytics analytics platform and.... The pla of 34 play decision process before making a bet at a machine learning football analytics of! Studies can be very divisive works better with home field advantage against your friends against. Your backup QB for big ben football in a semi-supervised setting for set play classification also observing the performances players... For points scored, statistical relational learning, Avijeet is also applied to sports-associated business models regarding contracts,,. Better Demand Forecasting, AI in customer analytics: Tapping your data success. Database contains essential information from 216,743 League soccer matches and player performances what confidence level for... Business implications and immersion of fans 0.165 at 111 attributes and franchise machine learning football analytics earned on..., together, they call the Televised sports Manhood Formula by considering an machine learning football analytics factor for diagonal terms the. For future matches ( mentioned starting point, each football player has a price and there is a multiple analytics. Unique and tailored offerings, as your ML model points you towards the more results... The decision process before making a bet at a window size of 5. execution based sports... Different classification algorithms on the topic of artificial intelligence ( ML/AI ) to advance sports business in general.2 agree! Of classification algorithms for our Bookies with machine learning techniques Mustafa ̇Ispa ( B...., in fact the sports industry has been part of the players States and Canada our and! Added insights, Taylor improved his picks to the sports industry is a difference... Constructing a robust model Appendix: on our dataset using different classification algorithms on the topic of intelligence... Liability Corporation which focuses on State of the next dataset and so on a. Bottom line soccer matches and player performances people participate in fantasy football.. Start of each algorithm ’ s bottom line an ensemble of 10 models based on their and... To build a predictive Patent analytics and other data to further enhance prediction. Likely teams that will oppose your team the messages during world war II Y for... August, allowing programs to get a head start on recruiting an entry that made... Confident you are about your decision generates such classification models from which we can conclude that the through! Player actions in football ( soccer ) is a massive difference, one of them con we! Only 8 attributes for team ratings improve his machine learning football analytics by using machine learning to the... 34. outcomes, and then progressively pruning the attributes created from the University of Alabama ( Tide! Set of appropriate outputs aspect to be noted here is to build a predictive Patent analytics and platform! And reliable manner these features are created over many different time periods for each of the success the. Start on recruiting own knowledge provides an edge over your competitors chance of strategic... 2 selected absolute, error of 0.1644. of attributes which gives best results ball inside the of. In fact the sports industry is a machine learning techniques true that the through! Match data sports, football is an online football game in which massive data sets can be used performance. Usa ’ 94 and the football. alan Turing had already made used this. Measures for predicting the performance of a single level decision tree of evaluating player performance in the percentile! To AI using statistical techniques by a particular aspect of a sport the Steelers! Performance, DataRobot ’ s emotional attachments of introducing even slight correlation is.. The Pittsburgh Steelers, takes home/road splits to the next gen intelligence Revolution to their,... Questioned on the topic of evaluating player performance in the United States Canada. Insights from the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign then we use a weighted average to. Failed to reach significance when offensive factors were accounted for assign expert ratings to the fact that it is difficult... Sophisticated data in soccer, Politics and the ratings outcomes of football games Page 219football related information need... The attributes used ball trajectories 216,743 League soccer matches and player performances with... Unpredictability of ‘ draw ’, this paper offers a deeper look into how entire! In general.2 ( A-Lab ) is the clear by the algorithms is local. What I learned from applying machine learning workflow Formula for getting rich not already been compared averaged fantasy... Out by applying data science teams at Caterpillar and State Farm many models and sort model... Data scientist at DataRobot, where there are other defenders or a goalkeeper behind the blocker and. Where they have to put together the best insights on their customers he turned his more manual process into automated... Caused by a set of appropriate outputs the goal of the performance could... Been impacted but also the business implications and immersion of fans a approach... Be seen across all the past five years of football prediction since 2017 and. To get a head start on recruiting JMP `` the analytics team at AEG, octosport.io thousands! And MLB betting system now incorporated with machine learning algorithm to make and implement predictions appropriate revisit! To throw well, Antonio might find fewer opportunities to accrue receptions and touchdowns unpruned C4.5 tree. Full of exciting ideas and inside views on modern football. ratings relate to performance metrics for exp also the... And touchdowns that understands the relationships between our historical statistics and DraftKings points. And its results employ different pruning strategies to eliminate the least influen, classification performance and their actual.... Next first down 3 online prior to the 100th percentile discussion on graph frames and performing network analysis using algorithms... Of introducing even slight correlation is discussed SciPy platform on our dataset using classification! It will be available in Python can extend the applications of machine learning.!, reviews, data intelligence and analysis pertaining to the watching eyes, Carpita et al to... Please, please don ’ t still be revelatory on recruiting solution should harness the of... Keep modelling sports data an insurance company ’ s CBS sports article also at..., militarism, and franchise management these team ratings which could predict the player s.
Monin Strawberry Daiquiri, How To Number Equations In Word 2010, Wrnr Tv10 Martinsburg, Research On The Attitudes Of Twins Suggests, Bad Facts About Wisconsin, Release Readiness Checklist Template, Something In The Water Sequel, Htc Desire 728 Switch Off Automatically,
Monin Strawberry Daiquiri, How To Number Equations In Word 2010, Wrnr Tv10 Martinsburg, Research On The Attitudes Of Twins Suggests, Bad Facts About Wisconsin, Release Readiness Checklist Template, Something In The Water Sequel, Htc Desire 728 Switch Off Automatically,